Butter ranked by protein density

Productkcal/100gProtein/100kcalCarbs/100kcalFat/100kcal
Avonmore Butter Milk 1 Litre615.6g8.2g4.9g
Lidl Deluxe Green Vegetable Medley with Seasoned Butter 250g1084g4.5g6.2g
Costa Coffee White Toast (without butter)2513.9g18.6g1g
Lidl Deluxe All Butter Scones 260g3482.6g15.9g2.7g
Lidl Deluxe Butter Cheese Puff Pastry Mini Twist Snack 90g5472.6g7.9g6.4g
Tesco 8 Butter Brioche Rolls3462.5g15.3g3g
Warburtons 8 Butter Brioche Rolls 280g3412.5g15.5g3.1g
Lidl Snaktastic All Butter Cheese Twists 150g5002.4g10.6g5.2g
St Pierre 8 Brioche Rolls with Butter3502.3g14.5g3.3g
Lidl Chef Select Herb Baguettes Filled With Herb Butter 3 x 175g3052.2g12.7g4.4g
Costa Coffee All Butter Sultana Scone3552g15.3g3.3g
Jacob's Butter Puffs 200g5011.9g11.7g5g
CONNACHT GOLD HALF FAT BUTTER3841.8g0.1g10.4g
Jacobs Butter Puffs5051.8g11.7g5g
Dunnes Stores Simply Better All Butter Cinnamon Swirls 400g3501.6g11.3g5.3g
Kerrygold Traditional Irish Butter Shortbread 50g5191.5g11g5.5g
St Pierre French Bakery 10 All Butter Mini Pains Au Chocolat4621.5g10.5g5.7g
Kerrygold Butter Shortbread 150g5131.4g12.1g5.3g
Lidl Deluxe All Butter Shortbread 150g4941.3g12.5g5g
St Pierre 6 Belgian Waffles with Butter4341.3g12g5.1g
St Pierre Belgian Waffle with Butter4341.3g12g5.1g
St Pierre Belgian Waffles with Butter 20 x 90g4551.3g11.6g5.3g
Lidl Deluxe Scottish Selection All Butter Classic Shortbread Rounds 160g5201.2g11.1g5.6g
Lidl Deluxe All Butter Caramel Sticks 150g5121.1g13.4g4.5g
Tesco All Butter Shortbread Fingers 210g5161.1g11.4g5.4g
Lidl Deluxe All Butter Chocolate Chip Shortbread Rounds 150g5171g11.8g5.3g
Lidl Deluxe All Butter Shortbread Rounds5351g11.2g5.7g
Dunnes Stores Simply Better All Butter Scottish Shortbread with Chocolate Chips 150g5150.8g12g5.4g
Centra Irish Creamery Butter 227g7400.7g0.7g11.1g
Centra Irish Creamy Butter 454g7400.7g0.7g11.1g
Lidl Deluxe Butter Fudge with Ben Bracken Highland Whisky 150g4270.3g18.2g2.8g
Flora Light Butter 550g2520.2g0.2g11.1g
Kerrygold Lighter Unsalted Reduced Fat Irish Butter 250g5630.2g0.4g10.8g
Aldi Cowbelle British Salted Butter 250g7410.1g0.1g11.1g
Aldi Cowbelle British Unsalted Butter 250g7540.1g0.2g11g
Aldi Meadow Flower Butter 500g5870.1g0.2g11g
Aldi Nordpak Lighter Butter Spread 500g5150.1g0g11.1g
Aldi Specially Selected West Country Butter with Sea Salt Crystals 250g7450.1g0.1g11g
Avonmore Butter7340.1g0.1g11g
Avonmore Irish butter7520.1g0.1g11g
Avonmore Pure Irish Butter7340.1g0.1g11g
Avonmore Pure Irish Unsalted Butter7520.1g0.1g11g
Avonmore Unsalted Butter 227g7520.1g0.1g11g
Dairygold Butter Churned Cream Mini Packs 150 x 7g7260.1g0.1g11.2g
Dairygold Butter Sticks 3 x 100g (300g)7120.1g0.1g11.2g
Dairygold Original Irische Butter7480.1g0.1g11g
Dairygold Plant Based Butter7280.1g0.2g10.9g
Dunnes Stores Irish Creamery Butter 454g7390.1g0.1g11.1g
Dunnes Stores Irish Creamy Butter 227g7390.1g0.1g11.1g
Dunnes Stores Taste of Butter 500g4860.1g0.1g11.1g

Showing the top 50 of the 120 butter products that carry a comparable calorie figure, ranked by protein per 100 calories. Figures per label, sourced from Open Food Facts and tracker user logs.

What the butter numbers show

Median across all 120 of them is 0.1g of protein per 100 calories. Not one of them clears 10g of protein per 100 calories, which is the line Keith uses for a food that pays for its calories.

Calories run from 48 to 884 per 100g inside this one group, an 18-fold spread, so “butter” on its own tells you almost nothing about what a portion costs you.

Own-brand is not the compromise here. The supermarket own-label median is 0.1g of protein per 100 calories across 39 products, against 0.1g for the 81 name-brand ones.

What to actually pick

Nothing here is a protein food, so treat it as calories. At a median of 0.1g of protein per 100 calories this group is a taste and energy decision, not a macro one.

106 of the 120 carry 400 calories or more per 100g — the ones worth weighing rather than eyeballing.

Where this fits

Front-of-pack claims on this stuff rarely match the back, so scan it with the label checker.

For one specific product rather than the whole group, the 20,000-product database is searchable on Calories in Ireland, and the same figures are built into the free calorie tracker.

FAQ

How many butter products are in this database?

We track 120 butter products across Irish supermarkets and brands. 120 of them carry 20 calories or more per 100g, which is the point below which protein per 100 calories stops being a real number, so those are the ones ranked and averaged here.

What's the most protein-dense butter product?

The table is sorted highest protein per 100 calories first, so the answer is the top row. The more useful number is that the median for the whole group is 0.1g per 100 calories and 0 products clear 10g — that tells you whether butter is worth buying for protein at all, which protein per 100g does not.